Introduction

1001 movies you must see before you die. Must I? Let's see.

My name is Dagmar and I am from Czech Republic. I have a bachelor's degree in screenwriting. I study movies. I watch movies. I write about movies. I kind of mention movies a lot. I even cross stitch things I like in movies. My views on cinema could be described as peculiar. My views on the "1001 movies" list as complicated. It happens a lot that I get the feeling it wasn't that necessary to see some particular movies. Sometimes I'm really grateful I saw them. And there are also times when I don't watch any new movies for six months straight. And they keep adding new movies every damn year so I might have to never die to watch them all.

What's the score right now?
606/1245 - That's 639 left to see.
I started this experiment on July 3rd 2009 and the latest update was made on April 19th 2023.

You can find the full list here.
Showing posts with label Germany. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Germany. Show all posts

Sunday, 20 January 2019

The Usual Suspects (1995)

USA/Germany
directed by: Bryan Singer
written by: Christopher McQuarrie
starring: Gabriel Byrne, Kevin Spacey, Chazz Palminteri
seen on 20th January, 2019

-"The man with the plan."

It's about as cool as a fireside story. Just after it finishes you might think "oh wow!", but if you start thinking about it for just a moment all the shapes start fading, the smoke and mirrors become apparent and the world within the story stops making any sense. 

I'd say the trouble is that Bryan Singer is probably the most overrated bastard, I mean director, I can think of, that is until I start saying it about somebody else. The story is very simple and has no other atributes than being cool and Singer still fails to 1) ground it in reality 2) populate it with characters with believable connections 3) make it self-aware. 

The film seems so outdated by concentrating so hard on this one gimmick up its sleeve. It forgets that we have to watch it even before the ending and that our attention should be misdirected and manipulated to look for something starkly different than the point it eventually makes. 

P.S.: Similarly mainstream films that do this misdirection the right way are for example The Prestige or even American Beauty to stay relevant. Try comparing these films and it won't be hard to see that The Usual Suspects are about "nothing". 

Wednesday, 12 December 2018

Crash (2004)

USA/Germany
directed by: Paul Haggis
written by: Paul Haggis, Robert Moresco
starring: Don Cheadle, Jennifer Esposito, Michael Peña
seen on 12th December, 2018

I have considered it a great deal and now believe that the main reason why this film sucks so bad (or seems to suck so bad) is the soundtrack. It's bad enought that the story tries to cram so many people in that they each get only about two or three scenes (which is not enough for a proper introduction, let alone for realizing a complete personal story arc) and therefore forces them to make their every word, move and action to directly aim at the ham-fisted message Haggis presents with the subtlety of a monty-pythonian knight in medieval armour punching someone with a rubber chicken. But that music, that wannabe touching, kitsch, one-dimentional music sends it to the gates of hell immediately and without any doubts. It showcases the inability of its creators to show some insight, to hide the meaning under the surface at least a little bit, engage the viewer to think about it or instigate any discussion other that why did it got the Oscar compared to all the other movies made and nominated that year. But if someone held a gun to my head and made me name one good thing about Crash, it would be Michael Peña.

Saturday, 7 July 2018

Bridge of Spies (2015)

USA/Germany/India
directed by: Steven Spielberg
written by: Ethan Coen, Joel Coen, Matt Charman
starring: Tom Hanks, Mark Rylance, Sebastian Koch
seen on 7th July, 2018

I watched this film about a month ago and I kept saying to myself: "I've got to give it some time to make up my mind" and I kept saying it for so long I nearly forgot I even watched it, and well, that about sums up my opinion.

To be a bit more specific, I was actually deliberating whether the praiseworthy "oh the humanity" theme can balance out the disgusting pro-american/patriotic tone of the whole thing that maybe could find its place in the black-and-white 1990s but surely not in the cinema of the 21st century. By using these outdated optics Spielberg and his team, that surprisingly (for me) includes the Coen brothers, prove that they are not able to step outside their own shadow and reflect not only the times in which their story is set but also (and more importantly) the times in which they are making their statement. I will illustrate my displeasure on an example: The part I theoretically liked the most in this film was a connection between two shots framing (or rather summing up) the story: the first one is where Hanks rides the train "from one Berlin to the other one" and sees people getting shot down while trying to climb "the wall". The other one is of course the one where he rides a city train back in his home country and watches kids cheerfully climbing fences during play time. But how can they present this with a clear conscience as a symbol of "oppression x freedom" in present-day America, knowing full well what present-day America does to children and with walls and fences - at home, towards USA's neighbours and in a lot of other countries around the world.

I could also possibly enjoy the character of Abel as presented by Mark Rylance, but what good is such a brilliant minimalist performance in a film where manipulation follows sentimentality. I also found it amusing how is the introductory scene for mr. lawyer written to make him look like the biggest douchebag imaginable (For some reason I kept imagining Quentin Tarantino in the role: "Not our guy, a client of our guy." I believe that could be the mark of a Coen.) but since he's being played by Tom Hanks he later on displays no signs of these character traits presented during this exposition and forever keeps on acting and talking like the best gosh darnest man in the world and its history. And that's about all I remember about this film.


Sunday, 13 August 2017

Downfall (2004)

Der Untergang
Germany/Italy/Austria
directed by: Oliver Hirschbiegel
written by: Bernd Eichinger + Joachim Fest (book), Traudl Junge (book), Melissa Müller (book)
starring: Bruno Ganz, Alexandra Maria Lara, Corinna Harfouch, Ulrich Matthes, Christian Berkel,
comment: 13th August, 2017

"All there is to know about Adolf Eichmann:

Eyes: medium
Hair: medium
Weight: medium
Height: medium
Distinguishing features: none
Number of fingers: ten
Number of toes: ten
Intelligence: medium

 What did you expect?
 Talons?
 Oversize incisors?
 Green saliva?
 Madness?"

-Leonard Cohen, Flowers for Hitler


Friday, 18 December 2015

Fight Club (1999)

USA/Germany
directed by: David Fincher
written by: Jim Uhls + Chuck Palahniuk (book)
starring: Edward Norton, Brad Pitt, Helena Bonham Carter
comment: 18th December, 2015

-"I felt like destroying something beautiful."

I've had several long years to think about Fight Club and here's my verdict: I don't understand at all what this film is about. I liked the back muscles of Helena Bonham Carter and I liked the dresses she wore. I liked it when Brad Pitt wore the white shirt with orange-red maple leaves together with the khaki camouflage trousers. I really, really don't like Edward Norton and it's still hard for me to comprehend that a person with zero charisma has such a succesful carreer and a wide fan base. And finally, I don't like it when a film makes a voiceover its alpha and omega this way. Voiceover should offer a new, twisted and contrasting layer, and not be film's only layer.


Saturday, 10 May 2014

The Grand Budapest Hotel (2014)

USA/Germany/United Kingdom
written and directed by: Wes Anderson
starring: Ralph Fiennes, Tony Revolori, Saoirse Ronan
seen: 10th May, 2014, additional comment: 6th May, 2018

I went to see the film with a boulder-sized migraine and it still managed to make me laugh out loud like crazy. I guess the less real the "Wes-world" is, the more amused/engaged am I. Maybe it's true that the idea seems to get a bit lost under the surface, but when I see other directors no more being capable to even do form/style properly in their new films (my recent disappointments include Jarmusch - Only Lovers Left Alive, McQueen - Twelve Years a Slave, Burton - just about anything he does these days, Jackson - the dreaded second trilogy) I am very glad that I can say that at least Anderson still knows his stuff.

2018: And thinking back I now one hundred percent don't think that the idea gets smothered by the surface. There's nothing wrong with different types of stories being told. (And I have to make an honorable mention of Saoirse Ronan, who I subconsciously hated ever since The Atonement, courtesy of the character she portrayed there. Well, thanks to the part she plays here my hatred is gone an I am free to notice in different films as well that she is in fact quite an interesting actress.)


Sunday, 14 February 2010

Inglorious Basterds (2009)


USA/Germany
written and directed by: Quentin Tarantino
starring: Mélanie Laurent, Daniel Brühl, Christoph Waltz, August Diehl
seen: 14th February, 2010 - comment upgraded: 11th February, 2018

Okay, so I keep re-watching "Inglorious Basterds" in hopes of finding out if I like the film or not. And the one that makes it so hard for me to decide is no other than Mr. director himself, because he balances every great thing about the film with two anti-great. He came up with his very own template for making films and now he just keeps filling and re-filling it and he will do so until the hell freezes over, I suppose. And the films are ironically more and more empty each time he does that. "Basterds" are very closely nearing it being untolerable, and because I am a traveller from the future, I know that it's only gonna get worse. Just as Lord Voldemort damages his soul each time he kills someone, thus becoming less of a human and more of a monster, so does Tarantino with every repeated, unbearably endless, not so funny and not so necessary monologue of one of his characters lose a bit of his reputation as an innovator and ingenious rehasher I once thought he was.

Recycling storylines and stylistic and musical themes from earlier films is overall a disease that "Basterds" are plagued with through and through. Maybe it's because he wrote the script through the years he worked on another projects, but that does not excuse the final feel of unoriginality. When I hear the music he put together with the Bride fighting the Crazy 88 or when I see a new parent using his new status during negotiations for his life, I am more annoyed than anything else, despite finding other moments of the film great.

And just when it seems I'm done blaming him for doing the same things over and over, I am going to say that there is one thing he didn't repeat and I almost feel like should have tried it, because this concept seems more interesting to me than the result we ultimately got: And that is his original plan which was, just as in "Kill Bill", to cut the whole story in two parts differing in tone, themes and style, and more complementing each other rather than needing each other. (But only if he had enough material to fill both parts with adequate content and not just wanna-be-cool ballast.) Because by not doing that, he got one film invisibly split in unequal parts that don't stick together very well and that is frackin' frustrating.

First of all, the film does look a lot like a rough cut of a much larger thing and that there was a lot more planned than what we got to see in the end - but the characters seem to know it happened and they suppose the viewer knows it too. But mainly, it creates the weird discrepancy between the main characters and the real and supposed influence they have on the story. Oh yes, I'm pulling out the good old argument that if the titular Bastards weren't in the film, not that much would have changed. Now I want to mention that I'm a big fan of film-makers giving the finger to handbooks and rules and doing whatever they want (and whatever their film needs to work out in the end). When it comes to Kill Bill, for example, I don't mind at all that Tarantino's jumping around like a happy kitten, showing us origin stories of side characters that don't matter all that much in the "main" story - because the mosaic fits so well in the end and there is no feeling of something being forced, false or barren, it makes sense by the logic of reason and emotion as well. "Basterds" don't give me this satisfaction.

I consider Shoshanna to be the main character of this film. It is her fate that gives structure to the whole thing. And the film tends to treat her a like a main character. For a while. I love how she keeps being forced to react to unexpected and brutal strikes from the strange and unknown. I very much love how the character of Fredrick Zoller works and operates and how brilliantly Daniel Brühl savours bringing him to life. And I simply adore how Tarantino uses the media image of them both to bring their story to a bitterly triumphant end. But Tarantino also wants more and more or maybe he got bored with only having one main story in his film so he keeps going even after what seemed like the perfect ending to me and suddenly decides that Bastars and Landa are the stars here and jumps with them to end the film on a different note, in a different place and also in a different genre altogether, and that's just a gargantuan disappointment for me. And just as final insult ment especially for me, crouching under the big screen in the dark, Tarantino cannont contain himself and has to utter the final remark about this being his masterpiece. Well, you know what, you nasty boy, it does not work for me, it does not. This film lacks the metaphorical suitcase emiting golden shine, so you can only dream on about this being a masterpiece at all.

P. S.: Out of the many, many situations in this film designed as exercises for actors to layer their abilities to show and hide just how much do their characters really know and don't know, what they play as actors and what they pretend as characters and so and so, I've decided to specifically mention Mélanie Laurent and August Diehl, because their performances are the best of the bestest.


Thursday, 26 November 2009

Pandora's Box (1929)

Die Büchse der Pandora
Germany
directed by: Georg Wilhelm Pabst
written by: Ladislaus Vajda + Frank Wedekind (book)
starring: Louise Brooks, Fritz Kortner, Francis Lederer
seen: 26th November, 2009, comment: 10th June, 2017

This film represents a rather unbalanced mix of blunt uncompromising and lengthy naivety. I guess this is how "destructive feminity" looks like when it's completely imagined by men. Up untill the courtroom scene Pabst presents the audience with beautifully and eloquently framed cruel theatre that would very well work without any additional intertitles. Then the genre/presentation shifts into some weirdly overcomplicated soap opera in an underground casino, where a lot of things sort of "transpire", but I think that this entire passage could be removed without any harm to the overall story and it would also lead to a much better, cleaner film. And the closing London chapter goes back to being great, mean, expressive and ultimately cinematic way of finishing what the director started in opening parts of the film.

So what I'm saying is that the film craft was executed splendidly, but the process of adapting the book story arc to a film story arc - not so much.

"It's strange how you can get booze on credit... but not bread."




Monday, 6 July 2009

The Lives of Others (2006)

Das Leben der Anderen
Germany
written and directed by: Florian Henckel von Donnersmarck
starring: Ulrich Mühe, Sebastian Koch, Martina Gedeck
seen: 6th July, 2009 - comment: 16th August, 2017

"Nein, es ist für mich." ♥♥♥ I'm trying to figure out if I'd admire this film as much as I do now if the main part wasn't portrayed by the biggest and most emotive eyes in the history of our universe, aka the eyes of Ulrich Mühe.

The film is cold and reserved, but I also read it as accuracy and self-awareness. And when you add the quiet thundering of the main leads with the ultimately charismatic Mühe in the center to the mix, I see an artwork that provokes no objections or wishes of additional changes in my mind.

It is a typical "Oscar-worthy" film, but it has some fairytale qualities and an elevating meaning as well, so I am truly crying, thank you and rest in peace, Mr. Mühe.


Monday, 24 November 2008

Dancer In The Dark (2000)

Denmark/Germany/Netherlands/USA
written and directed by: Lars von Trier
starring: Björk, Catherine Deneuve, Peter Stormare, Siobhan Fallon Hogan
seen: 24th November. 2008, additional comment: 30th July, 2017

2008: Well, I'm having a dilemma. I've been on several dates with Mr. Trier before and I've been, so far, almost always thoroughly amazed. But I am also a bit of a skeptic and I have hard time believing in the existence of such geniuses, so to get to my point, I was prepared to be as critical as humanly possible when I set out to watch Dancer in the Dark.

The film starts slow and easy, almost making the viewer (me) wondering how it can ever reach the ending it's supposed to reach. And then the viewer stops thinking about such nonsense as she's being dragged in by the power of the extraordinary point of view on such ordinary reality. The song "I've seen it all" has a devastating effect on the emotionaly disturbed girl and makes her completely identify with the heroine. The sudden story twist screams: "I am illogical. I don't seem to organically belong. I am forced to the extreme!" The viewer's brain is working double shifts to understand it and then the disarraying ending wreaks havoc in the subconsciousness.

And now back to first person writing: All in all, even though the movie disagrees with me at some points and I do not think it's perfect the way I think Dogville is perfect, for the accurate work of describing the inner world of a resigned dreamer I am forced to give it highest marks.

-"You've never been to Niagara Falls?" -"I have seen water, it's water, that's all..."

2017: As I get older, my disagreeings with this film stay the same but my love for it grows bigger and bigger. The formal principle of combining the shaky docu camera for the "normal" life and montages of many static shots for the musical numbers is able to manipulate the viewer's point of view so brilliantly it deserves the highest praise solely for that. But wait, there's more. The actors work so accurately that every scene seems to be the best acted scene ever to be best acted. In some imaginary world I have no trouble ripping my heart from my chest, splitting it in half and giving those halves to Peter Stormare and Siobhan Fallon Hogan.

-"What is there to see?" ♥♥♥


Friday, 10 October 2008

Bowling For Columbine (2002)

USA/Canada/Germany
written and directed by: Michael Moore
starring: Michael Moore, Charlton Heston, Marilyn Manson
seen: 10th October, 2008 - comment: 21st October, 2015

Seven years ago I wrote about this documentary that I found it entertaining. Now as the only truly entertaining thing remains the statement that bowling might be as much a plausible influence on the shooters as anything else.

Moore probably has good intentions, but I'm not sure about the direction of the road he's paving with them. A lot of the situations look like they could have been handled differently... and mostly more smartly. The thing that hasn't changed during the years I had to think about this film is that I still consider the couple of sentences Marilyn says to be the intellectual (and most likely argumentational) peak of the film, and since he didn't even got to say that much, that paints a pretty accurate picture of the film's depth.


Tuesday, 29 January 2008

The Bourne Ultimatum (2007)

USA/Germany/France/Spain
directed by: Paul Greengrass
written by: Tony Gilroy, Scott Z. Burns, George Nolfi
starring: Matt Damon, Julia Stiles, Joan Allen
seen: 29th January, 2008, comment updated 24th March, 2018

With each new viewing the film becomes less and less engaging. A few more rounds and I guess I'll think it's a stupid flick. (And I feel the need to add that it's simply depressing that the storyline of "the Ultimatum" is just a mosaic of essential plot points from both previous films and doesn't bring almost anything new to the mix. The core example of this is when Bourne causes a car crash to get rid of "the terminator" chasing him, confronts him at gunpoint and then decides to spare him in order to be more human himself - that's exactly the same freaking thing that happened in "the Supremacy", except that Karl Urban is replaced by Edgar Ramirez in the part of the pretty psycho-killer. That's pure impertinence to recycle a scene like this, to use old emotions instead of evoking new ones. As far as screenwriting goes, this is unforgivable.)

But because of the hearbreaking stare of Daniel Brühl (about whom I have briefly forgotten that he even shows up in this film because I'm always admiring the plants in his film appartment, mainly the ficus by the window and the bonsai at the door) I have decided to list some positives as well and to not end my review on such an angry note. The scene with the journalist at the London train station is truly spectacular and probably my favourite sequence of the whole trilogy. And I guess it's kind of cute how he sends the entire agency out for a walk in New York. But the final act is so unsatisfying in throwing everything away and starting to target irrelevant emotions that I always end up losing interest. And even the final Moby beings to sound a bit worn out.

-"Get some rest, Pam. You look tired."